News & publications
Filters
Our funds
Media

Quarterly earnings: a season fraught with risks
Trees do not grow to the sky. And yet, following a second quarter that delivered historically strong earnings per share (EPS) growth*, consensus expectations ahead of the reporting season stood at +18% and +29% year-on-year growth in Europe and the United States, respectively. While such levels have been seen before in equity markets, they were typically associated with rebound periods, when base effects were favourable. The current situation is quite different, with oil and AI-related spending driving corporate profits higher. But with expectations running this high, companies have little room for error, making a progress update essential.
Unusually, it is in Europe that we are seeing the biggest positive surprises this quarter, with EPS growth reaching 26% year on year. This remarkable performance is a reminder of how equity markets can provide a distorted reflection of the region's underlying economic activity, owing to the sector composition of the index. A large part of this increase can be attributed to the oil sector, which has become impossible to overlook since Iran and the United States began vying for control of the Strait of Hormuz**. Excluding what some might consider a one-off effect, growth looks more modest, at +15%.
Given the significant weight of banks in the European index's earnings, the sector has attracted particular attention from investors. Despite several quarters of upward earnings revisions, it continues to post a positive earnings surprise rate above that of the broader European market. However, its growth is converging towards that of the index, as aggregate net interest income becomes less dynamic (+14%).
As in the previous quarter, earnings growth is not confined to these two sectors, with six of the remaining eleven sectors recording double-digit expansion over the period. Utilities bring up the rear, with EPS declining by 1%, reflecting a combination of base effects, exceptional items and the lagged impact of higher hydrocarbon costs.
In the United States, a positive earnings surprise rate above its historical average has enabled the index to post year-on-year EPS growth of 31% for the quarter. And while the energy sector*** is delivering the strongest growth, ahead of technology, it is the latter that investors were looking to for answers. Hardly surprising, given that technology accounts for more than 40% of S&P 500 earnings.
From an earnings perspective, the sector has delivered, with technology companies reporting a 90% positive surprise rate and 70% earnings growth over the period. However, it was not so much the income statement as the cash flow statement that caught investors' attention: in aggregate, hyperscalers' cash generation fell from $62 billion in Q3 2025 to -$27 billion this quarter, prompting the Financial Times to describe the group of five companies as "cash incinerators"!
Looking at individual companies, Alphabet, Google's parent company, was the hardest hit in market terms. The company's second negative free cash flow quarter since its 2004 stock market listing was compounded by an unexpected slowdown in advertising revenue from its flagship search engine. Conversely, Microsoft was the only player to stand out positively this quarter, reassuring shareholders with evidence of financial discipline.
However, the biggest disappointment came from chipmaker Intel, which served investors an unpalatable mix of declining gross margins, a slowdown in the PC end market and negative cash generation. Given the semiconductor sector's exceptionally crowded positioning, the stock's 28% decline on the day of its results — its sharpest fall since 1974 — will come as little surprise to market observers.
Despite these isolated setbacks, it is worth noting that the proportion of US index constituents raising their guidance is at its highest level since 2021, at more than 60%. As a result, earnings growth forecasts for 2026 and 2027 have continued to be revised upwards, not only in the United States but also in Europe. At the time of writing, analysts' consensus forecasts point to growth of 18% in the United States and 9% in Europe next year.
In the shorter term, since the US 10-year government bond yield peaked at 5.30% on 5 October, equity markets have shifted towards a more defensive stance, driven in part by renewed concerns over the monetisation of AI-related capital expenditure. Within the S&P 500, consumer discretionary and healthcare stocks have therefore led sector performance since that date, at the expense of technology.
The outcome of the midterm elections has only reinforced this trend, with investors questioning whether companies will be able to deliver on their AI infrastructure deployment plans in a less supportive political environment.
These "under-the-surface" movements have translated into significant outperformance by the S&P 500 Equal Weight Index relative to the standard S&P 500, which is inherently more concentrated****. This market environment should be interpreted by investors as a compelling case for greater sector and geographical diversification through to year-end.
* EPS growth of 33% in the United States and 19% in Europe in Q2, year on year.
** Year-on-year EPS growth of 151% for the European oil sector in Q3.
*** Year-on-year EPS growth of 153% for the US oil sector in Q3.
**** The AI Top 10 (the Magnificent Seven, Broadcom, AMD and Micron) accounts for approximately 40% of the S&P 500.
Pierre Pincemaille, General Secretary of Investment at DNCA. This article was finalised in November 13rd, 2026.
This promotional document is a simplified presentation and does not constitute a subscription offer or an investment recommendation. No part of this document may be reproduced, published or distributed without prior approval from the investment management company.
DNCA Investments is a trademark held by DNCA Finance










